Reynolds turned in a pair of victories and a second-place finish as the Pioneers battled it out in the pool against Ashland.
She won the 50 freestyle with a time of 24.86 to give the Pioneers nine points in the team standings.
In the 200 freestyle relay, Reynolds was part of the winning team with Denise Quentin, Kinsey Knoch and Macy Williams, as they combined for a time of 1:39.36, second fastest in Malone’s history.
She finished off her strong dual meet performance with a time of 1:04.65 in the 100 backstroke, touching the wall for the second in the race.
The Pioneers will be hosting the G-MAC/MEC Championships back in Canton for the third straight year later in Februrary at the C.T. Branin Natatorium.