#9 Oilers Outlast #14 Augustana 23-20 in Playoff Overtime Thriller

11.21.26

By: University of Findlay Athletics



Findlay, Ohio – The University of Findlay football team, ranked No. 9 in the country, did something it had never done in the NCAA era of the program on Saturday, Nov. 21, win a home playoff game. Facing No. 14 Augustana University (S.D.) in the opening round of the NCAA Division II Playoffs at Donnell Stadium, the Oilers survived a thrilling back-and-forth battle to claim a 23-20 victory in overtime.

The triumph marks just the second NCAA DII Playoff win in program history, joining the 2017 squad that went on the road to upset No. 2 Shepherd in the first round. Now 11-1 on the season, Findlay has also set a new NCAA-era program record for victories and recorded the most wins by any Oilers team since the 1997 squad went 14-0 on its way to an NAIA national championship. Augustana sees its season come to a close at 9-3.

"That's what playoff football is all about, right? That level of competition," Findlay head coach Tyler Johns said afterward. "It comes down to the wire, takes 60 minutes and then a little bit more after that, and I'm just really proud of these guys. Our leaders stepped up in a big way today on a day where you were going to need those guys that are the cornerstones of your program to step up and play well."

For Johns and the Oilers, the historic afternoon also had deeper meaning as the program honored the memory of legendary former head coach Dick Strahm, who passed away over the summer.

"We've talked a lot this year about our past and the history of this program," Johns said. "With Coach Strahm's passing this past summer, that's something that we've not shied away from. We've spoken a lot about returning that glory. When we started this whole thing, we set a goal that at the end of the day, we wanted to make him proud. And today, I think we did."

Saturday's matchup pitted strength against strength, featuring an Augustana offense that entered the weekend ranked ninth nationally in total offense against a Findlay defense ranked No. 1 in the country in scoring defense (9.5 points per game), rushing defense (68.4 yards per game), and total defense (226.3 yards per game).

Findlay's defensive front made its presence felt on the very first snap of the afternoon. A high snap sailed over the head of Augustana quarterback Gunnar Hensley for a 15-yard loss, immediately putting the Vikings behind the chains and forcing a quick punt.

Following a Findlay punt on the ensuing possession, the Oilers caught a massive break when Augustana muffed the return and linebacker Josh Woods pounced on the loose ball at the Vikings' six-yard line. Although Findlay could not punch it into the end zone, kicker Zachary Barzd converted a 19-yard field goal to open the scoring at the 8:13 mark.

"It's playoff football, where every point is going to matter," Johns said of electing to kick from inside the five. "In that moment, I felt like the best thing for us was to start the day with the scoreboard going our way first."

The Oilers' defense forced another three-and-out, capped by a combined sack from Levi Oxley and Elijah Shankle, and Findlay wasted no time extending its advantage. Quarterback Chase Harrison connected with Denny Furlong for a 34-yard gain on the first play of the drive before capping the four-play, 38-yard march with a four-yard touchdown run, quickly putting Findlay up 10-0 with 5:23 remaining in the opening quarter.

Augustana was not phased by the early deficit, leaning heavily on Hensley, who entered the postseason ranked second nationally in both passing yards (3,753) and total offense per game (349.4). The Vikings answered early in the second quarter when Hensley capped an eight-play, 77-yard drive with a nine-yard touchdown pass to Klayton Sattler to trim the lead to 10-7.

Findlay responded with a crucial scoring drive just before the half. Facing a fourth-and-one at the Augustana seven-yard line, Harrison kept the ball himself to move the chains and later found 6-foot-5 freshman tight end Caleb Miller for a six-yard touchdown pass on the next play with just 15 seconds left in the second quarter, sending the Oilers into the locker room with a 17-7 cushion.

"Caleb, he's a stud," Harrison said. "He's a freshman, so early on you're still trying to get a grip of the playbook and everything. He's hit the ground running. When you see a 6-5 receiver like that, it's pretty easy to know where to go with the ball."

The shootout continued in the third quarter as Hensley found Sattler again, this time from 26 yards out, to pull the Vikings within three. A 44-yard kickoff return by Dominic Bennett set up Findlay in prime field position, and Barzd drilled a career-long 49-yard field goal to push the Oilers' lead back to 20-14.

Augustana chipped away in the fourth quarter, connecting on a 39-yard field goal by Jake Pecina before orchestrating an 18-play, 74-yard march deep into Findlay territory. Pecina later had a chance to win it for Augustana as time expired, but his 56-yard attempt missed wide left, sending the contest to overtime.

Findlay won the toss to start the extra period and choose to defend. On third-and-six, Hensley fired toward the end zone, where Oilers safety Luke Weihrauch stepped in front of the pass for an interception at the two-yard line.

"I definitely should have had that one at the end of the fourth quarter there," Weihrauch said. "I was kind of kicking myself, and then my teammates really stepped up to get that goal-line stand, forcing them to kick a field goal. That was really big. In overtime, we showed two-high and were able to confuse them maybe a little bit, and I just saw the ball in the air. I had to make a catch on it for sure. I'm definitely just grateful to my coaches for putting me in the spot to make that play, and it was honestly God giving me a second chance."

Needing only a score to secure the victory, Findlay gained five yards on three plays to set up Barzd, who, after a timeout by the Vikings, calmly split the uprights from 37 yards out to seal the 23-20 win and spark a celebration on the Donnell Stadium turf.

"I didn't say anything to him," Johns joked afterward. "I'm too superstitious for that. I said something to him in Week 2 and I haven't spoken to him since. He just goes and does his thing, and for Zack to come up big at the end, what an awesome moment for him and for this football team."

While Hensley threw for 330 yards and two touchdowns, Findlay's top-ranked defense clamped down on the ground, holding the Vikings to just 55 rushing yards on 27 carries, and forced three turnovers. Defensive lineman Elijah Shankle etched his name into the program record books with five tackles and his first-quarter half sack, bringing his season total to 12.5 and breaking the single-season school record set by Nate Arnold in 1995.

"There was a part of today where we kind of said, 'Hey, D-line, you're going to be the ones that win this game for us,'" Johns said. "It was going to be about rattling a kid that hasn't been rattled all year and making him uncomfortable. For Shank to go and get it early, that was such a cool moment for him. He had no idea. I went over and congratulated him and he looked at me like I was nuts, because it's not about him, it's about the bigger picture, the team, and the program."

Weihrauch, who led the team with ten tackles on the afternoon, echoed that sentiment about Findlay's front four, adding, "Look at Shank, he's a freak. All those guys really just put their nose to the grindstone and go to work every single day, and I'm grateful they're on my team."

Oxley led the pass rush with two sacks, Walter Berry Jr. added a key third-quarter interception in the red zone, and Josh Woods added nine stops, a TFL, and a fumble recovery.

Offensively, Harrison finished 25-of-37 passing for 212 yards and a touchdown while adding 26 yards and a score on the ground. Bennett led all Findlay receivers with seven catches while Furlong tallied a team-high 52 receiving yards on three receptions.

"It's kind of easy to play quarterback when you have 10 other guys around you really doing well, doing their job," said Harrison, who transferred to Findlay prior to the 2025 season. "Being here is the happiest version of myself. I'm so grateful that Coach Johns, we sat down earlier before the season even started, and I chose him, he chose me to be able to stay here and play. Being able to be with these other 100 guys is an honor."

Augustana outgained Findlay 385 yards to 253, but the Oilers converted all three of their fourth-down attempts and won the turnover battle 3-1 to advance.

With the victory, Findlay moves on to the second round of the NCAA Division II Playoffs next Saturday, Nov. 28 where they will take on the two-time defending national champion Ferris State University Bulldogs in Big Rapids, Mich.